If an automated interview rejected you or returned feedback that seems wrong, you can ask for a human review, request an explanation of what was assessed, check whether a technical problem (audio, accent, language, a dropped connection) affected your score, and, in several jurisdictions, rely on rules that give you notice and alternative-process rights. None of that guarantees a reversal, but it is more than most candidates do, and the same steps prepare you for the next automated round. This page sets out what to ask for, how to ask, the technical causes of bad AI scores, and what the law says in plain terms; it is general information, not legal advice.
What to ask for
- A human review. Many employers will have a recruiter look at a rejected candidate's recording or transcript on request, especially if you give a specific reason.
- An explanation. What was assessed, on what criteria, and whether the decision was made by the tool alone or with a person.
- The technical record. Whether your audio was complete, whether the transcript is available to you, and whether the system logged a problem.
- An alternative. A live interview or a different format, which some rules require employers to offer; see can you ask for a human instead of an AI interview.
- Your data. In places with data-access rights, a copy of what was collected and the evaluation.
How to ask
Write to the recruiter or the address in the invitation, within a few days, briefly and without anger. Name the role and the date, say that you believe the automated assessment may not reflect your answers, give one specific reason (the audio cut out during question three; English is my second language and the transcript may have errors; the feedback cites a topic I was never asked about), and request a human review and an alternative format. Keep a copy. A calm, specific email gets read; a long complaint does not. What normally happens after an automated round, and how long results take, is covered in what happens after an AI interview.
Technical causes of unfair scores
| Cause | What it does to the score | How to check and prevent |
|---|---|---|
| Poor audio or a dropped connection | Missing or garbled transcript, scored as a weak answer | Ask for the transcript; use a wired connection and a headset next time |
| Accent or second-language speech | Transcription errors read as incoherence | Speak slightly slower in complete sentences; see AI interview bias: what candidates should know |
| Answers that were too short | Scored as lacking evidence | Sixty to ninety seconds with a structure |
| Talking over the prompt | The start of your answer is lost | Wait a beat after the question ends |
| Background noise or cross-talk | Fragments attributed to you | A quiet room, a closed door |
What the rules say, in plain terms
Several jurisdictions regulate automated hiring tools. New York City requires bias audits and advance notice for automated decision tools and a way to request an alternative; Illinois requires notice and consent for AI analysis of video interviews; the EU treats AI used to evaluate candidates as high-risk, with transparency and human-oversight duties for employers, and EU data law gives you access and explanation rights; several US states have further rules in force or in progress. Everywhere, ordinary discrimination law applies to decisions made with AI assistance. The details by place are in AI interview laws and candidate rights. If you believe the decision was discriminatory, a local employment-rights body or a lawyer is the right next step.
Preparing for the next one
- Practice the automated format until it is routine: questions read aloud, a timer, a two-second pause, complete sentences.
- Test your audio setup the day before and use a headset.
- Keep your own notes of what you were asked and what you said, immediately afterwards.
- Ask up front whether a human alternative is available if the format worries you.
Where CoPilot Interview fits
CoPilot Interview is an AI interview assistant whose free AI mock interview rehearses the automated format directly: questions read aloud, spoken answers scored out of ten with reasons, a transcript you can read afterwards, so the next AI-led round holds no surprises. The free plan gives 15 minutes a day of live help in sessions of up to 15 minutes, with AI mock interviews included. In the automated round itself, outside help is not allowed; prepare beforehand, keep your own record, and follow your employer's rules and the invitation's instructions.
Disclosure: CoPilot Interview is our product, so weigh what we say about it accordingly.
Frequently asked questions
What can I do if an AI interview rejected me unfairly?
Ask in writing for a human review, an explanation of what was assessed, the transcript or technical record, and an alternative format; in some jurisdictions you have formal rights to notice and alternatives.
Why would an AI interview score me badly if my answers were good?
Often a technical cause: poor audio, a dropped connection, transcription errors with accents or second-language speech, answers that were too short, or talking over the prompt.
Do I have legal rights about AI interview decisions?
In several places, yes: notice, alternative-process and data-access rights, and bias-audit requirements for employers, plus ordinary discrimination law everywhere. This page is general information, not legal advice.
How should I word a request for human review?
Briefly and calmly: the role and date, one specific reason the assessment may not reflect your answers, and a request for human review and an alternative format.
Practice this interview before the real one
The AI mock interview builds questions from your resume and the job description, reads them aloud and scores each spoken answer out of 10. Included on the free plan.
Start a mock interview